Two Brothers Pizzeria

Two Brothers Pizzeria brings a slice of New York soul to downtown Butler, Pennsylvania, just a few blocks from the historic Butler County Courthouse. Founded in 1998 by brothers Marco and Vinnie Castellano, the shop continues to use the family’s hand‑tossed, cold‑fermented dough and homemade red sauce simmered for hours. The menu showcases classic New York‑style options such as Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, and the towering Meat Lovers Pie, as well as specialty Grandma and Sicilian slices baked in a brick oven that gives the crust its signature chew and crisp edge. Side dishes include garlic knots, cheesy breadsticks, and cinnamon‑sugar sticks, all finished with a butter‑parmesan garnish. Every pizza can be customized with a wide range of toppings—pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, banana peppers, and more—while the first two toppings are free and each additional topping adds a modest fee. A 4% cash discount applies to all items, and new customers enjoy free delivery on orders over $25 with the code BROTHER25. The interior is a casual, family‑friendly space with vintage New York memorabilia, open‑kitchen visibility, and a counter that serves both dine‑in and take‑out guests. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Two Brothers Pizzeria is a go‑to spot for pizza night, quick lunches, and late‑night cravings, delivering the authentic taste of the Big Apple to western Pennsylvania.