Toscanella Village Cafe

Toscanella Village Cafe is a beloved family-owned Italian restaurant located at 102 Kings Highway in Middletown Township, New Jersey, serving the community since 2014. This authentic pizzeria has become a local favorite for its handcrafted pizzas, including the popular Plain Cheese Pizza at $11.00, the classic Margherita Pizza with fresh mozzarella and oregano at $13.95, and the hearty Sicilian Pizza priced at $18.95. The menu features an impressive variety of specialty pizzas such as White Pizza with its creamy ricotta, mozzarella and parmesan blend, the savory Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, and the Grandma Pizza with fresh basil pesto. Appetizers are equally impressive, featuring crispy Fried Calamari with marinara, tender Mussels with White or Red Sauce, and the beloved Garlic Knots baked to golden perfection. The restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for family dinners, with outdoor seating available during warmer months. Their extensive menu includes fresh salads like the Tosscanella Salad with romaine and iceberg lettuce, hearty hot subs including the famous Chicken Parmesan Sub at $9.95, and made-to-order paninis. Open seven days a week, Toscanella Village Cafe provides online ordering for convenience and accepts reservations for larger parties. With a Google rating of 4 stars from 155 reviews, this Middletown institution continues to deliver authentic Italian cuisine with warm hospitality and generous portions.