The Island Shoppe

The Island Shoppe Ice Creamery on Grand Island, NY, blends two Western New York icons—Perry’s Ice Cream and Red Osier Roast Beef—under one family‑run roof. Situated at 1966 Whitehaven Road, just minutes from Niagara Falls, Tonawanda and Buffalo, the shop welcomes locals and tourists alike with a bright, retro‑styled interior featuring vintage signage, reclaimed wood tables and a wall of colorful ice‑cream tubs. Over 30 Perry’s flavors rotate seasonally, from classic vanilla bean and chocolate fudge to regional favorites like Maple Walnut and Strawberry‑Basil. Signature sundaes pair the creamy scoops with house‑made whipped cream, toasted nuts, and a drizzle of warm au‑jus, the savory sauce that accompanies the thin‑sliced Red Osier Roast Beef sandwiches. The roast beef, sourced from a local butcher, is served hot on a soft roll with the au‑jus, offering a hearty contrast to the sweet treats. Owner‑operators Vinny and Josephine Ciffa, a husband‑wife team, greet guests by name and often share stories of the brand’s heritage. The menu also includes milkshakes, banana splits, and a selection of locally crafted swag such as enamel pins and tote bags. Open daily from 12 pm to 9 pm, the shop provides curbside pickup and delivery via phone or the website. Prices range from $3 for a single scoop to $12 for a deluxe sundae, making it an affordable indulgence for families. Whether you’re stopping after a day at nearby Niagara attractions or looking for a neighborhood hangout, The Island Shoppe promises a nostalgic, flavor‑filled experience that turns strangers into family.