Stumpy's Pizza & Subs

Stumpy's Pizza & Subs is a beloved family-owned pizzeria located at 1331 E Northern Ave in Phoenix, Arizona, serving the community since 2001 when Chase and Debi Herrick took over this beloved establishment. This old-school mom-and-pop pizza shop has earned a cult following among neighborhood residents and beyond, thanks to its commitment to authentic Italian-inspired cuisine made from scratch daily. The menu features hand-tossed pizzas crafted with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, which owner Chase Herrick proudly declares as the best in America, paired with only the highest quality tomatoes. Beyond their renowned pizzas, Stumpy's is famous for their generous sandwiches - the Classic Italian hot sandwich is the most popular choice, while the Big Dipper featuring roast beef, smoked provolone, and garlic butter on a crispy Italian roll comes in at a close second. All sandwiches can be customized with their homemade mayonnaises, including unique habanero and chipotle flavors that add a delightful kick. The menu also includes classic Italian dishes such as lasagna, manicotti, and baked ziti that customers describe as unusually great. Stumpy's offers convenient delivery Tuesday through Friday from 10am to 8:30pm, with a minimum order of $20 and a $4.99 delivery fee. Pickup and dine-in options are also available, with the shop open Tuesday through Friday 9am to 9pm and Saturday 9am to 4pm.