Sonny's Pizza II

Sonny's Pizza II is Hackettstown's beloved hometown pizzeria, serving the community since 2002 with consistently excellent pizza and Italian-American fare. Located at 915 County Road 517, this family-owned restaurant has earned a reputation as a hidden gem in Warren County, New Jersey. The restaurant is renowned for what customers consistently call the best garlic knots in NJ, along with their impressive gluten-free pizza and pasta options that cater to dietary restrictions without compromising flavor. Owner Mike and his team create everything to order using the freshest ingredients available, ensuring each dish meets their high standards. The menu features an array of specialty pies including the popular Grandpa and Grandma pie, the creative Big Mac pizza, and the indulgent Disco fries pizza. Beyond pizza, guests rave about the honey mustard chicken wrap, hearty pasta dishes, crispy buffalo wings, chicken parmigiana sandwich, and fresh taco salads. Sonny's offers convenient online ordering through Toast, with delivery serving Hackettstown, Allamuchy, Liberty, Long Valley, and Andover. The restaurant also provides excellent catering services for events and gatherings. With over 400 reviews averaging 4 stars, Sonny's Pizza II continues to be the go-to choice for locals seeking quality Italian cuisine in a friendly, welcoming atmosphere.