A Slice Of Brooklyn

Nestled at 808 E Main St in the heart of New Holland, Pennsylvania, A Slice Of Brooklyn brings a slice of Brooklyn’s iconic pizza culture to Amish Country. The brick‑walled dining room features an open kitchen where you can watch dough being tossed, while vintage sports memorabilia lines the walls, creating a relaxed vibe perfect for families and game‑day crowds. Their menu showcases classic Margherita and cheese pizzas, but the real stars are the Brooklyn Full House Pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, green peppers and extra cheese, and the Grandma Pizza—a thin‑crust, garlic‑infused masterpiece finished with pesto and pecorino romano. For wing lovers, the Tuesday‑Thursday special offers a free order of boneless wings with any large gourmet pizza, and Sunday’s Game Day specials pair three large cheese pizzas with 20 boneless wings for $54.99. Gluten‑free diners aren’t left out; the gluten‑free pizza and lasagna are crafted with the same fresh ingredients. Appetizers like loaded fries, mozzarella sticks, and perogies add variety, while salads such as the Caprese and Antipasto provide a lighter touch. Open from 10 am to 8:40 pm, the restaurant welcomes take‑out, delivery, and curbside pickup. Prices range from $3 slices to $25 specialty pies, offering value for every budget. Whether you’re a local craving a familiar taste or a tourist exploring Lancaster County, A Slice Of Brooklyn delivers hearty portions, friendly service, and a true Brooklyn vibe.