Rusty Nail - Cape May Iconic Beach Bar

The Rusty Nail, affectionately known as 'The Nail' by locals, stands as Cape May's legendary surfer bar and restaurant that has been capturing the laid-back beach vibe since the 1970s. Located at The Beach Shack on Beach Avenue, this iconic establishment was famous for having what was rumored to be the longest bar in all of Cape May, where lifeguards, surfers, and beach bunnies gathered in the heyday. Today, Chef Jimmy Burton brings big flavors and a relaxed atmosphere to The Rusty Nail, serving dishes that celebrate Cape May's coastal charm using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients from Beach Plum Farm. The restaurant offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily with the kitchen open from 8:00am to 10:00pm and the bar operating from 11:00am to 11:00pm. Families will appreciate the kids' meals served on souvenir Beach Shack Frisbees, while four-legged friends are warmly welcomed both indoors and on the outdoor sand bar. The venue features an indoor fireplace for cooler evenings and a popular fire pit during summer months. Named by Travel+Leisure as one of America's Top Ten Beach Bars, The Rusty Nail hosts regular events including High Tide Happy Hour, Surfside Sunday, Smokin' Tuesdays, and the annual Doggie Pageant. The restaurant operates on a first-come, first-served basis with no reservations accepted, embodying the truly casual beach shack experience that has made it a beloved Cape May institution for generations.