Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson

Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson brings the vibrant tastes of Mexico to Muncie, Indiana, serving authentic dishes that celebrate rich culinary traditions. Located at 508 S. Tillotson Avenue in the heart of Muncie, this welcoming restaurant has become a local favorite for both dine-in and takeout. The menu features an impressive array of Mexican classics, from sizzling fajitas topped with grilled peppers and onions to crispy chimichangas stuffed with tender shredded meat and smothered in savory sauces. Guests rave about the hearty Torta Mexicana, a substantial sandwich piled high with traditional fillings on fresh bread, and the innovative Fajita Piña, which combines the smoky flavors of fajitas with the tropical sweetness of pineapple. The beverage menu offers refreshing Mexican drinks like authentic agua de limón, traditional Cantarito cocktails made with tequila and fresh citrus, and the popular Strawberry Margarita crafted with ripe strawberries. The restaurant operates seven days a week, with convenient hours from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on weekdays and adjusted times on weekends. Online ordering makes it easy to enjoy Puerto Vallarta's authentic flavors at home, while the warm, festive atmosphere perfect for family gatherings and casual dining with friends. With nearly 2,000 reviews averaging 4 stars, Puerto Vallarta-Tillotson delivers consistent quality and genuine Mexican hospitality to the Muncie community.