Old Mill Tavern

Old Mill Tavern is a beloved historic restaurant located at 55 Route 24 in the charming town of Chester, New Jersey. Founded in the 1800s, this establishment originally served as a post office and general store for the then-named town of Milltown before being rebuilt in 1918 after a devastating fire. The restaurant has been a local fixture for over 50 years, currently owned by John and Virginia Butkus since 2016. Step inside to discover 24 beers on tap, classic American cuisine, and a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like home. The tavern is renowned for its impressive collection of over 100 military and first responder patches displayed throughout the venue, honoring those who serve and protect our communities. Veterans, police, fire, and emergency personnel receive a special 10% discount every day. Situated directly across from the historic Nathan Cooper Grist Mill, Old Mill Tavern offers a unique blend of rich history and contemporary dining. Whether you're seeking craft beers, hearty American fare, or a piece of New Jersey's culinary heritage, this tavern delivers an authentic experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. Open daily for lunch and dinner, parking available on-site.