Nags Head Pizza Company

Nags Head Pizza Company, established in 2017 and relocated in 2022, has become a beloved fixture in the Outer Banks dining scene. This family-owned pizzeria operates from a charming historic building at 4036 S Virginia Dare Trail—originally the Nags Head Post Office that was later converted into a Montessori school before being transformed into the restaurant you see today. The owners take tremendous pride in their commitment to fresh ingredients, highest quality foods, and healthy, diverse menu options that appeal to both locals and vacationers. Whether you're craving a classic margherita, a loaded specialty pie, or exploring their creative seasonal offerings, Nags Head Pizza Company delivers the authentic, handcrafted pizza experience that the OBX is known for. The restaurant's welcoming atmosphere reflects the warm, community-oriented spirit that has made it a favorite among residents and visitors alike. Order online for convenient pickup or delivery, or enjoy your meal on the scenic deck overlooking the beautiful Nags Head sunset. With nearly 1,000 Google reviews averaging 4 stars, this pizzeria has earned its reputation as one of the best pizza destinations on the Outer Banks. Open daily for lunch and dinner, Nags Head Pizza Company welcomes families, couples, and groups looking for delicious, quality pizza in a relaxed, friendly environment.