Nancy's at the Lake

Nancy's at the Lake is a beloved ice cream shop and fast food destination nestled in the heart of New Buffalo, Michigan, just steps away from the beautiful Lake Michigan shoreline. Since opening its doors in 1978, this family-owned establishment has been serving the community and visitors with delicious frozen treats and classic fast food fare that keeps people coming back year after year. The shop features a nostalgic retro exterior with outdoor seating perfect for enjoying your treat on a warm summer day while watching the activity on North Whittaker Street. Inside, you'll find a cheerful atmosphere with friendly staff ready to serve generous portions of soft-serve ice cream, sundaes, floats, and a variety of frozen desserts that rival any Michigan ice cream shop. The menu also includes hot dogs, burgers, and other quick bites that make Nancy's a perfect stop for lunch or an afternoon snack. Located in the popular tourist destination of New Buffalo, the shop sees both loyal locals and vacationers who have been making the pilgrimage to this Michigan lakeside town for generations. Whether you're exploring the nearby beaches, shopping in the downtown area, or simply passing through on your Lake Michigan adventure, Nancy's at the Lake offers that classic small-town ice cream shop experience that defines summer in the Midwest. The shop operates seasonally and opens daily at 11am, closing in the evening after serving the dinner crowd.