Mugsy's Mercantile

Mugsy's Mercantile is a celebrated sandwich shop nestled in the heart of Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey, where Chef Meg LaManna—winner of Food Network's Chopped—serves up an exceptional menu of handcrafted sandwiches, seasonal salads, and artisan soups. Located at 629 Arnold Ave just steps from the beach, this charming eatery has become a cornerstone of the Jersey Shore culinary scene. The menu showcases creative combinations like the signature Mug's Sub featuring house-roasted turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian aioli on a semolina roll, while the Steak Caesar wraps tender sliced steak with little gem lettuce, capers, and homemade croutons. The Cyprus Chicken piles spiced chicken breast with tabbouleh, crumbled feta, and tzatziki on ciabatta, and the Smoked Hawaiian combines shaved smoked ham with grilled pineapple and coconut crema on brioche. Health-conscious diners rave about the Fresh Tuna Salad with yellowfin tuna, capers, mint, and vegan mayo, and the Ocean Raised Salmon salad with apples and dill. All sandwiches can be customized with gluten-free sourdough or wraps. The shop also offers private event catering through Chef Meg's dedicated service, perfect for celebrations along the shore. Open Thursday through Sunday from 11am to 4pm, Mugsy's welcomes walk-ins and strongly recommends preorders for their grab-and-go offerings. The outdoor sidewalk tables provide the perfect spot to enjoy your meal while soaking in the relaxed beach town atmosphere.