Mama Carolla's

Mama Carolla's is a beloved Italian restaurant nestled in the historic Meridian-Kessler neighborhood of Indianapolis, Indiana. Housed in a stunning 1920s California Stucco villa that was originally built as a model home by the RH Shelborn Company, this restaurant offers an intimate and authentic Italian dining experience that has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike for decades. The interior retains much of its original Mediterranean-inspired design, including exquisite wrought ironwork and period light fixtures that create a warm, inviting atmosphere. During winter months, a crackling wood-burning fireplace fills the dining room with cozy warmth, perfect for enjoying classic Italian cuisine. Mama Carolla's has earned numerous accolades, including being named TripAdvisor's 2022 Highest Rated Italian Restaurant in Indianapolis, earning a spot on MSN.com's Best Italian Restaurant in the State, and receiving the OpenTable 2022 Diners' Choice Award. The restaurant also appears on USA Today and Yelp's Top 50 Most Romantic Restaurants list. The menu features authentic Italian dishes made to order, with thoughtful gluten-free options including gluten-free penne pasta available for most entrees and pasta dishes. Reservations are limited, with the majority of tables available on a first-come, first-served basis, and groups of six or more are encouraged to call directly to arrange their visit.