John's of Arthur Ave.

John's of Arthur Ave. is a beloved family-owned pizzeria located at 115 Seventh St in the heart of Milford, Pennsylvania. For over 13 years, owner Colin Smith has been serving authentic Italian pizza made with love, empathy, and an unwavering commitment to quality. Growing up working in his uncle's bakery alongside his mother and grandfather, Colin brings generations of culinary tradition to every dish he creates. The pizzeria is renowned for its Detroit-style Motown pizza with its signature crispy corners, classic New York style slices, and thick Sicilian pies. Every pizza features fresh dough made daily in-house, locally sourced ingredients, and authentic sauces prepared from scratch. Beyond pizza, the menu offers hearty pasta from the Arthur Ave Pasta Shop, crispy wings, generous appetizers, fresh salads, and decadent desserts including ricotta doughnuts and cannoli. The Graffiti pizza has become a local favorite among the innovative specialty pies. Generous weekly specials make dining affordable for families, including Monday large cheese pizzas for $11.99, Wednesday $5 off Detroit pizzas, and a remarkable 3-course dinner complete with appetizer, entree, and dessert for just $24.99. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and exceptional customer service keep locals returning week after week, with many customers praising the staff's kindness and the delivery driver's thoughtful phone call before arrival. Catering services are available for events and gatherings. Open for lunch and dinner, John's of Arthur Ave. continues to be Milford's destination for authentic Italian-American comfort food.