Hole Lot of Bagels

Hole Lot of Bagels has been serving the Middletown community for over 30 years, becoming a beloved neighborhood institution since opening in 2003. Located in the Middletown Marketplace at 1171 NJ-35, this family-owned bagel shop specializes in kettle-boiled and baked bagels that are crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The shop opens daily at 6am, offering both pickup and delivery services for early morning breakfast orders. Their signature menu items include the famous Porkroll, Egg and Cheese on an Everything Bagel with their special "saltpepperketchup" seasoning, the Middletown Grill sandwich with pork roll, bacon, egg and cheese, and their Super French Toast. Cold sandwich options are served on your choice of bagel, wrap, Kaiser roll, wheat, white or rye bread, piled high with premium cold cuts including premium ham, salami, bologna, oven gold turkey, honey turkey, roast beef, and pastrami. They also offer house-made flavored cream cheeses, rainbow bagels, Bialy's, bagel twists, and gluten-free options. The shop takes pride in its community involvement, supporting local organizations, schools, and charities through donations and fundraisers. With a Google rating of 4 stars from 189 reviews, Hole Lot of Bagels continues to deliver what they promise – a "Hole lot of Love" in every order.