BYOC Build Your Own Cookie

BYOC Build Your Own Cookie is a beloved dessert destination on Chincoteague Island, Virginia, serving the Eastern Shore community since 2009. This charming ice cream shop specializes in cookie sundaes featuring warm, homemade cookies paired with your choice of Hershey's ice cream flavors and delicious toppings. The unique concept allows guests to build their own perfect treat, choosing from chocolate chip, peanut butter, fudgy brownie, and other cookie varieties, then customizing with ice cream, sauces, whipped cream, and more. Beyond cookie sundaes, BYOC offers classic ice cream cups and cones, thick milkshakes, ice cream floats, waffle cone sundaes, and edible cookie dough for those who want to skip the baking. The shop features outdoor seating at custom-built construction site-themed tables and picnic areas, with iconic lit-up construction cones adding to the playful atmosphere. Owners Wendy and Kent Massey have created a welcoming space perfect for enjoying dessert after a day at the beach. The Chincoteague location sits at 6503 Maddox Boulevard, conveniently located near the island's popular attractions. A second location opened in West Ocean City, Maryland in 2019, expanding their reach across the Eastern Shore. Gift cards and BYOC merchandise including t-shirts and kids' hard hats are available.