Benny Tesoro's Pizza

Benny Tesoro's Pizza, affectionately known as Benny's, is a legendary pizza destination nestled in the heart of Nags Head, North Carolina's beloved Outer Banks. This iconic pizzeria has become a must-visit spot for locals and tourists alike, serving what many consider to be the region's most impressive pies. What sets Benny's apart is their famous 28-inch jumbo pizzas, each one capable of feeding six to eight hungry diners. The menu features an impressive array of specialty creations, including the crowd-pleasing Wild Bill Buffalo Chicken with its bold buffalo sauce and tender chicken, and The Versace, a flavorful combination of roasted peppers and onions tossed with aromatic garlic pesto. For those who prefer classic flavors, the regular menu offers time-honored options like pepperoni, Italian sausage, and garlic mushroom, all priced affordably with both slice and whole pie options available. The restaurant's convenient location on South Virginia Dare Trail makes it easily accessible for beachgoers and residents of the Outer Banks community. Benny's operates seven days a week, with flexible hours accommodating both lunch and dinner crowds, and offers convenient pickup and delivery services for those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home or on the beach. With a solid 4-star rating from over 225 reviews, Benny Tesoro's Pizza has established itself as a cornerstone of the Nags Head culinary scene, consistently delivering quality, generous portions, and that authentic pizzeria atmosphere that keeps customers coming back year after year.