A Family Affair Italian Deli & Catering

A Family Affair Italian Deli & Catering has been a beloved Fair Lawn institution since 2011, serving authentic Italian cuisine that keeps locals coming back for more. Located at 23-17 Broadway in the heart of Fair Lawn, this family-owned deli has earned a reputation for exceptional sandwiches, homemade dishes, and reliable catering services. The deli recently came under new management with an exciting new look while maintaining the same great food that made it a community favorite. Signature sandwiches like the Soprano Hero (#25), featuring prosciutto, ham, capicola, sharp provolone, and hot peppers on crusty semolina bread, have been praised by food critics including Elisa Ung of The Record, who described it as 'for the hard-core guy that likes real Italian sandwiches.' The Godfather sandwich is another customer favorite, while the prosciutto and cheese rice balls have developed a loyal following. The menu extends beyond sandwiches to include steamed vegetables, broccoli florets with garlic, oil and parmesan, and eggplant rollatini. A Family Affair offers full catering services with half trays starting at $35, making them perfect for family gatherings and office events. The deli is also available on DoorDash, GrubHub, and Uber Eats for those craving their authentic Italian flavors at home. Their Stamp Me loyalty program rewards customers with free sandwiches, and the friendly staff ensures every visit feels like family.